0

Top 10 Most Comfortable Mattresses

 The Ultimate Mattress Buying Guide

I’m a firm believer that the best thing you can do for your overall health and well-being is to get a good night sleep every night.

When it comes to getting your necessary rest, a good mattress makes all the difference. When it came time to replace my old mattress, I wanted to make sure I was getting the very best one to ensure pleasant nights for years to come.

I sought the help of experts and tested countless mattresses before creating this list of my Top Ten Mattresses to help you find the most comfortable mattress for you.

I’ve chosen one mattress from each price bracket for each type of mattress: memory foam, hybrid, and innerspring to help you decide what is the most comfortable mattress for you.

Memory Foam Mattresses

Sealy Optimum Elation Gold

The Basics

The Elation Gold is a member of the Optimum line by Sealy Posturepedics. This mattress was designed to provide the comfort and support of memory foam with the temperature regulating benefits of OptiCool gel.

Sealy Posturepedics specializes in memory foam mattresses that form to the body while you sleep for a feeling of sleeping “in” your mattress instead of sleeping on top of it. Their mattresses are designed and built in the United States and offer a 10-year warranty.

What I love about this mattress:

• OptiCool gel technology helps you stay cool while falling asleep for a more restful sleep.
• Memory foam isolates motion so your sleeping partner won’t be woken up when you move.

What could be better about this mattress:

• More users than usual report sagging or loss of support within three years of owning this mattress.
• This mattress is on the heavier side, with the queen weighing in at about 100 lbs, which makes it more difficult to move.

The Bottom Line

• The OptiCool gel maintains a cool temperature while you sleep.
• The Sealy adjustable base allows you to position the mattress at an angle if desired.

This mattress is a great choice among the available memory foam models available today. Its cooling technology is great for those who have trouble sleeping when it’s warm, and the support is great.

Who is this mattress for?

The memory foam core supports the body, making it an ideal choice for those with chronic pain. If you suffer from lower back pain especially, you might find this mattress supports your back most effectively. This mattress can be used by side, back, or stomach sleepers alike.

Key Benefits

This mattress is made up of four unique layers that work together to provide overall comfort and support to ease pain and give you a restful night of sleep.

• 2″ of OptiCool gel with OUTLAST Gold to provide cool temperatures
• 4″ of OptiSense memory foam that conforms to your body for added support
• 7″ gel OptiCore bottom layer adds deep support with a denser material at the base of the mattress
• Optimum foundation designed to prolong the life of the mattress

The OptiCool gel regulates temperature to help you fall asleep faster, making this an ideal choice for those who struggle with warmer weather or falling asleep.

The inner layer of OptiSense memory foam provides support to the entire back to alleviate pressure and eliminate back pain as you sleep.

The bottom OptiCore layer provides added support to the back and pressure points throughout the body to relieve pain all over.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

Overall, this mattress is a great choice among the leading memory foam options on the market.

If you have back pain that makes it difficult to sleep, I recommend this mattress because of its great spinal support. If it’s within your budget, this is a great mattress to check out.

Lucid 14″ Plush Memory Foam Mattress

The Basics

This mattress is a comfortable dual-layer memory foam option with a top layer that gives the feel of a plush mattress topper. It has a moisture control cover made with a Tencel fabric blend to cover its three complete layers of support.

Lucid Mattress specializes in efficiently delivered, comfortable mattresses. Their materials are all independently tested to become CertiPUR-US® certified.

All their materials are free of toxic chemicals and lead, so this is a great choice if you’re concerned about the material quality of your mattress.

What I love about this mattress:

• The top bamboo charcoal layer prevents odors and removes extra moisture while you sleep for a comfortably dry fit.
• There is an added layer of memory foam gel that has the feel of a plush mattress topper, which gives this mattress the support of memory foam and the softness of a plush mattress.
• The entire mattress comes vacuum-sealed for easy delivery and set up.

What could be better about this mattress:

• This mattress releases organic compounds while decompressing, so it will have an odor for the first 1-4 days. The odor is safe, but some find it very unpleasant.
• The plush top gives a less firm feeling than you might expect out of a memory foam mattress.
• It takes 1-2 days to fully expand after you open it, so keep this in mind when planning your purchase.

The Bottom Line

• A top layer of charcoal-infused bamboo keeps moisture at bay and eliminates odors throughout the life of the mattress.
• Two layers of memory foam provide complete support.
• A bottom layer of dense foam provides even support for your back and body during the night.

This mattress is super comfortable and available for a great price. I think this is a great value, and the ease of shipping makes it easy to set up. As a lower-price mattress, it lacks the frills of higher-priced mattresses, but it’s a great option nonetheless.

Who is this mattress for?

Memory foam gives the support needed for anyone with back or joint problems. The top layer of memory foam has a plush feel, so those who prefer a softer mattress but still want the support of a memory foam mattress will like this option. It is appropriate for side, back, and stomach sleepers alike.

Key Benefits

This mattress is made up of three layers to offer support and comfort for the entire body. The bottom layer of dense form offers total support while the middle memory foam gel layer provides a plush feeling on top of that support. The top layer of charcoal-infused bamboo eliminates odors and moisture.

The most obvious benefit of this mattress is its back support as a memory foam mattress. It supports the spine evenly, allowing space for your body to move during the night without pain. If you suffer from back pain, this mattress is a good choice for you.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 25 year warranty and a 120 day money back guarantee.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

The comfort and convenience of this memory foam mattress and its vacuum-packed shipping are great, and the low price is even better. For anyone on a budget, I recommend this mattress as one of the top low-priced options you can find.

Shea 10-inch Memory Foam Mattress by Sleep Innovations

The Basics

This mattress contains two layers of memory foam designed to alleviate pain in pressure points throughout the body. It has a medium level of firmness that’s soft enough to be comfortable while still giving lots of support.

Sleep Innovations is a smaller mattress company that focuses on innovative mattress designs that are specialized for your personal style of sleeping. Their sleep lab focuses on reducing pressure points and increasing REM sleep.

What I love about this mattress:

• Two layers of memory foam offer strong support and soft comfort for deep sleep.
• Memory foam conforms to your body for a snug, supportive fit.
• Two free memory foam pillows are included with each mattress.

What could be better about this mattress:

• This is a low-price mattress that comes without the frills and newer technology of luxury brands.
• Its vacuum-sealed packaging takes 1-2 days to fully expand, so plan for this when purchasing.

The Bottom Line

• SureTemp memory foam keeps you cool as you sleep.
• Support-Plus foam provides firm support underneath for long-lasting firmness.

This mattress is a no-frills, simple option that’s great for anyone on a budget. Its low-price tag doesn’t mean you’ll have to sacrifice comfort.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress is especially suitable for side or back sleepers. The memory foam aligns with the spine to create an even line with the body, alleviating pressure points. If you sleep on your back or side and suffer from aches and pains, this mattress might be the one for you.

Key Benefits

The dual layers of memory foam provide soft comfort and firm support at a great price for anyone on a budget. Designed especially for side and back sleepers, this mattress is made to eliminate pain and keep the body cool while you sleep.

The top layer of this mattress helps keep you cool while you sleep, which helps people with insomnia to fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer. The memory foam support helps to relieve back and joint pain during the night by taking the pressure off pressure points throughout the body.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 20-year limited warranty.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

For anyone on a budget, this mattress has everything you need in a memory foam. It provides great support and is very comfortable despite its low price. I recommend this for anyone on a tight budget, but for those that can afford the Lucid mattress (#2 above), the extra cost is worth it in the long run.

Hybrid Mattresses

 

Stearns and Foster Lux Estate Hybrid

The Basics

This hybrid mattress combines the flexible support of a traditional innerspring mattress with the cushioned comfort of memory foam. Each coil is coated in foam for comfort and stability throughout the sleeping surface.

Stearns and Foster is a luxury mattress brand that focuses on handcrafted, high quality mattresses. This is the only hybrid mattress offered by the company, which usually specializes in dense memory foam mattresses.

What I love about this mattress:

• It’s super comfortable. The hybrid of innerspring and memory foam is close to the traditional mattress feel you’re probably used to, while the memory foam adds comfortable support throughout.
• Memory foam provides support to the entire back while the springs allow for movement and a bit of bounce.

What could be better about this mattress:

• Despite coming from a trusted luxury brand, these mattresses are not known for their longevity and many customers report sagging after only a few years.
• The springs and memory foam combine for a dense mattress that can be difficult to move.

The Bottom Line

• IntelliCoil technology provides cushioned springs that adapt to your body to provide the right amount of support.
• Air vents provide airflow to keep the mattress ventilated throughout its life.
• Memory foam with cooling technology provides a cooler sleeping surface.

This mattress is a luxury hybrid with a lot of great features for comfort and support. It is in the higher price range, and for a luxury-priced mattress its longevity leaves something to be desired.

Who is this mattress for?

If you have back pain and want a memory foam mattress but like the feel of a traditional innerspring mattress, this is a great choice for you. This mattress provides spinal support for those with back issues, and the rebounding effect of the springs provides additional support.

Key Benefits

This mattress has a base of coated springs for adaptable support, an inner layer of cooling memory foam, and a top layer of memory foam for support that moves with you as you sleep.

The middle memory foam layer regulates temperature as you sleep, helping those with insomnia or other sleep difficulties to sleep better. The memory foam provides support for the joints and spine, making it great for anyone with back pain or aching joints. This support works with the movement of the inner springs to provide adaptable comfort as you move.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty with strict limitations.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

Overall, this mattress is a comfortable, high quality luxury choice. However, its high price without the promise of a long-lasting mattress doesn’t make it worth the purchase for me. If you want a luxury mattress that may not last for longer than 3-5 years, this mattress is a good fit for you, but if you need a more sustainable option for your money, look to the other two options for hybrid mattresses below.

BeautyRest Platinum Brittany

The Basics

This hybrid mattress has the support of a traditional innerspring mattress with the same comfort you’d expect of a memory foam mattress. Its coils are in the base of the mattress to avoid pressure points and uncomfortable spots.

BeautyRest is a trusted brand that has been in business for over a century and continues to look for new ways to provide comfortable mattresses people can afford.

What I love about this mattress:

• The surface has cooling fibers that draw heat away from the body while you sleep.
• The memory foam is designed to hold its support while allowing for movement during the night.

What could be better about this mattress:

• This mattress is taller than other hybrids, making it an awkward fit for some bedrooms.
• This brand is not known for its durability, and numerous customers have reported the mattress starting to sag within the first 7 years.

The Bottom Line

• The top layer of fibers provides cooling comfort to remove heat from your body as you sleep.
• An inner contour layer provides support that forms to your body.
• Available in a variety of firmness levels.

This is a quality hybrid mattress for its price range, and the comfort is great. It gives you the support of a memory foam with the plush comfort and movement of an innerspring mattress.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress is good for side, back, and stomach sleepers, and it provides support for anyone with back or joint issues. If you want the traditional feel of an innerspring mattress but you also want the extra support and cushion of a memory foam mattress, this is a good choice for you.

Key Benefits

The bottom layer of springs provides cushioned support that moves with you as you sleep to provide the traditional comfort you’re used to. The upper layers of memory foam and temperature-controlling fibers keep you cool and supported while you sleep.

If you have back and joint pain, this mattress provides the support you are looking for in a mattress. It provides relief from tension throughout the body and keeps your spine aligned as you sleep.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty and is made in the United States.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

This is a great hybrid mattress at a reasonable price, and it provides great comfort and support. The springs inside keep the mattress bouncy while the memory foam helps keep your back aligned for comfortable rest. If this is within your budget, I recommend this hybrid option.

Sealy Posturepedic

The Basics

This is a hybrid mattress with individually wrapped inner coils for independent movement to support the body where it needs it most. The combination of memory foam and inner coils provides comfort and support that’s the best of both worlds.

What I love about this mattress:

• The inner coils can move independently to support your body where it needs it most.
• Extra support around the edges of the mattress makes it more durable to sit on and keeps the surface of the mattress even over its lifetime.
• Durable handles make for easier moving and set up.

What could be better about this mattress:

• This mattress releases off gas when it first arrives. These organic compounds are harmless, but you will want to give the mattress time to air out before sleeping on it.
• Its innerspring nature gives it a shorter lifespan than memory foam mattresses. Some customers report having to replace the mattress after only a few years, however the warranty does cover sagging mattresses.

The Bottom Line

• Individually wrapped coils allow for independent movement to support your curves.
• A 2.5-inch reinforced border keeps the mattress level when seated.
• The inner foam core and top memory foam layer work together to add comfort and support.

If you didn’t know this mattress was in the lowest price range, you might guess it’s a luxury mattress when you sleep on it. It’s comfortable, supportive, and has all the sleep technology of more expensive models.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress is great for anyone who wants the feel of a traditional mattress with the support of a memory foam. The coils support your back and spine, so those with back problems can benefit from using this mattress.

Key Benefits

The inner coils move freely to support your curves as you sleep, and the memory foam layers provide plush comfort.

If you suffer from back pain, this mattress provides the spinal support you need due to its combination of coils and memory foam. It also relieves pressure on joints, which is great for anyone with aching joints during the day.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 10-year warranty.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

This is one of the most comfortable low-priced mattresses I tried. It provides great support and it has the same technology as some of its higher-priced competitors. If you need great back support and the movement of an innerspring mattress, I recommend this hybrid as a great choice for any budget.

Serta Observer Super Pillow Top

The Basics

Part of their iComfort line, this mattress combines the comfort of a standard innerspring mattress with the support of a memory foam. It has individually wrapped coils to provide independent movement, and its inner core is made of gel memory foam.

What I love about this mattress:

• The coils are individually wrapped to allow them to move independently. This gives more support where you need it without placing extra strain on your body.
• The inner memory foam is super comfortable.
• A cushioned pillow top adds an extra plush sleeping surface.

What could be better about this mattress:

• Some people prefer not to have additional padding on top of their memory foam.
• This mattress does not have handles to help with set up and moving.

The Bottom Line

• Individually wrapped coils allow for independent movement to support your body wherever it needs it.
• The gel memory foam provides a firm core to the mattress and gives support to the spine.
• This mattress is compatible with Serta’s Adjustable Foundations platforms that allow you to sleep at an angle if desired.

This is another great hybrid choice that gives the support of inner coils that line up with your body’s curves to provide great support. The inner memory foam and the cushion top make it very comfortable to sleep on.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress is a good fit for side, back, and stomach sleepers, but side sleepers will especially benefit from the individual coils. They move to fit your body’s natural curves to keep your spine from bending during the night.

Key Benefits

The inner coils fit your body closely while the memory foam provides added support to the back. The cushioned top provides added comfort that hugs your body.

If you are a side sleeper who experiences a sore back in the morning, this mattress will help you keep your spine aligned while you sleep. People with back problems will also benefit from this mattress’s memory foam and coils combination. Lower back problems are especially helped due to the extra padding on top of the memory foam.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 10-year warranty and 120-day in-home trial.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

This mattress is very comfortable and it provides support right where you need it. If you can afford the slightly higher price tag, this is a top choice among hybrid mattresses. I recommend this one for anyone with a higher budget, but for those looking to spend less, the Sealy Posturepedic is the next best option.

Innerspring Mattresses

Sealy Traditional Innerspring

The Basics

This is a traditional innerspring mattress that offers individually encased coils for independent movement. It has cooling gel foam to keep the temperature low while you sleep.

What I love about this mattress:

• It’s a modern remake of the classic mattress with individually wrapped coils for independent movement.
• Its gel foam layer keeps the mattress cool throughout the night.
• Its solid edge allows you to sit on the mattress and keep the bed level while doing so.

What could be better about this mattress:

• Traditional innerspring mattresses offer less structured support than some memory foam models.
• Many customers report sagging and loss of shape after only 3-4 years.

The Bottom Line

• Individually wrapped coils allow for independent movement for complete support.
• The inner gel foam keeps you cool all night long.
• The outer edge remains intact to create a usable bed surface.

This is a classic with an important upgrade to allow the coils to move independently. It hugs your body where you need it, but it also gives the movement and plush feel of traditional innerspring mattresses.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress is best suited for back sleepers because the inner coils keep the spine supported, but do not move as much as side sleepers might prefer. If you suffer from lower back pain, this mattress is a good choice.

Key Benefits

The coils move to fit your body and the top layer provides a plush feel for comfort and support throughout the night. Cooling gel maintains an even, cool temperature while you sleep to help you fall asleep and stay asleep.

If you have back pain, especially in the lower back, this mattress can give you the support you need. It keeps the spine straight and relieves pressure from the lower back.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a warranty of up to 10 years.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

This is a great choice among innerspring mattresses, and the price is great as well. It provides the support of individual springs that move with your body, and it comes in several firmness levels to fit your personal sleeping preferences.

Signature Sleep Signature 13 Inch Independently Encased Coil Pillow Top Mattress

The Basics

The movement and support of independent coils is topped with a thin layer of memory foam for a comfortably plush top. The inner core is made with CertiPUR-US® certified foam to offer safe support for your whole body.

What I love about this mattress:

• With only an inch of memory foam, it’s almost a hybrid yet it has all the benefits of an innerspring mattress.
• Its coils are independently wrapped for freedom of movement to support your whole body.
• It is shipped compressed and vacuum-sealed for easy set up.

What could be better about this mattress:

• The coils and inner foam make this mattress heavy, so set up can be difficult.
• Innerspring mattresses are not known for their durability, so you can expect this mattress to sag after a few years.

The Bottom Line

• Individually wrapped coils allow for independent movement for complete support.
• The firm center supports the back and hips.
• Made without heavy metals, lead, or flame retardants.

This mattress provides great support and extra comfort with its cushioned top. It’s free of harmful chemicals to ensure a safe bedroom.

Who is this mattress for?

This mattress was designed to support the back and hips, making it perfect for those with back pain. It works well for side, back, and stomach sleepers.

Key Benefits

The coils move independently to provide support all over while the cushioned top keeps the back and hips aligned.

This mattress supports the back and hips to eliminate back pain and keep pressure off your joints. It’s an especially good option for those with lower back pain.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 1 year limited warranty.
• Where to find it: Available at Amazon

For a low price, this is a great innerspring option that has extra padding to keep your hips happy. It’s a great choice for those with back pain, and I recommend this mattress for anyone with lower back pain.

Ikea HAUGESUND

The Basics

This is a simple innerspring mattress with individually coated springs and lots of padding to keep it soft. It’s a more basic model that’s still very comfortable to sleep on.

What I love about this mattress:

• The individual coils move with your body for the right support where you need it.
• The inner padding is soft and plush.
• It is compressed and vacuum-sealed for easy set up.

What could be better about this mattress:

• It’s a more basic model without any memory foam or pillow-top padding.
• Despite its great warranty, any innerspring mattress can’t be expected to last more than a few years without sagging a bit.

The Bottom Line

• Independent coils give unique support to each area of the body.
• Plush padding keeps you comfortable as you are supported.

This is a basic mattress that will last you a long time and keep you comfortable throughout its lifetime.

Who is this mattress for?

This is a great choice for back and side sleepers who need spinal support to keep their back straight. It also helps alleviate back pressure with its individual coils.

Key Benefits

The padding keeps you comfortable while firm, individual coils give support in all the right places.

If you suffer from lower back pain especially, this is a great choice because it relieves pressure from the lower half of the spine with its coils.

Final Verdict

• Warranty: This mattress comes with a 1 year exchange period and a 25-year limited warranty.
• Where to find it: Available at Ikea

For its low price, this is one of the best mattresses you can find at Ikea. It offers great comfort and support while being the least expensive mattress on this list. It’s great for those with back pain, and it comes vacuum-sealed for easy set up. I highly recommend this mattress to anyone on a budget.